Audience 9.1 - A beautiful recording with a terrific drum sound, and expansive, atmospheric ensemble mix of all instruments especially keyboards to pair with that drum sound. This might be one you go to frequently. Genesis 1978.07.29 Madison Square Garden, N.Y.C.   The Set List: Disc 1 01 -intro 02 -Eleventh Earl of Mar 03 -In The Cage 04 -Burning Rope 05 -Ripples 06 -Deep In The Motherlode 07 -Fountains of Salmacus 08 -Ballad Of Big 09 -One For The Vine   Disc 2 10 -Squonk 11 -Intro to Say It's Alright Joe 12 -Say It's Alright Joe 13 -The Lady Lies 14 -Cinema Show 15 -Afterglow 16 -Follow You, Follow Me 17 -Dance On A Volcano 18 -Drum Duet 19 -Los Endos 20 -I Know What I Like (with Peter Gabriel)

Various Sources 9.0 - I give this a high rating for many reasons, as it can be easily assumed that the sound quality will vary being a compilation. The producers were smart to put it together this way, I found it to play much like a legitimate record company release. The worst of the recordings is in itself not even that bad, in the context you are hearing it in, it takes on new significance. I myself did not realize how few times some of these songs were played live, so having a collection like this makes sense. I enjoyed it immensely. So will you. Genesis Collection of Rare Live Recordings 1970 - 1998 Track List: Disc One: 1970-1972 01. Looking For Someone (2-22-1970) 02. The Light (3-7-1971) 03. Twilight Alehouse (2-26-1972) 04. Harlequin (3-4-1972) 05. Bye Bye Johnny (4-14-1972) 06. Happy The Man (4-18-1972) 07. Going Out To Get You (4-18-1972) 08. One-Handed Drum Solo (6-28-1972) 09. Can-Utility And The Coastliners (8-20-1972) 10. Seven Stones (8-22-1972) Disc Two: 1972-1975 01. Supper's Ready (11-18-1972) 02. Harold The Barrel (1-20-1974) 03. Horizons (5-4-1974) 04. Watcher Of The Skies (1-24-1975) 05. It (1-24-1975) 06. The Musical Box (1-24-1975) 07. The Waiting Room (5-2-1975) Disc Three: 1977-1978 01. Lillywhite Lillith-The Waiting Room-Wot Gorilla (01-01-1977) 02. All In A Mouse's Night (01-02-1977) 03. Inside And Out (06-24-1977) 04. Down And Out (06-07-1978) 05. Supper's Ready (From Apocalypse In 9/8) (06-14-1978) 06. Ballad Of Big (07-29-1978) 07. I Know What I Like (In Your Wardrobe) (07-29-1978) 08. Dancing With The Moonlit Knight-Musical Box (Closing Section) (10-13-1978) Disc Four: 1980-1984 01. Back In NYC (29-06-1980) 02. Me And Virgil (27/-09-1981) 03. Like It Or Not (30-11-1981) 04. The Knife (23-12-1981) 05. No Reply At All (22-08-1982 - Featuring Phenix Horns) 06. Paperlate (22-08-1982 Featuring Phenix Horns) 07. 11th Earl Of Mar - Squonk - Firth Of Fifth (11-10-1983) 08. 11th Earl Of Mar - Behind The Lines - Firth Of Fifth - Musical Box (17-01-1984) Disc Five: 1986-1998 01. In The Cage - In That Quiet Earth - Supper's Ready (10-15-1986) 02. Mama (05-09-1992) 03. Carpet Crawlers (10-23-1992) 04. Nowhere Else To Turn (Unreleased B-Side) 05. Small Talk (12-13-1997) 06. Thats All (01-23-1998) 07. Hold On My Heart (01.29.1998) Details: A wonderful live collection that gives you some of the rarest Genesis performances from throughout their career. Even if you're a collector of every individual show this is still a keeper to have, one reason being the unreleased track on disc 5, "Nowhere Else To Turn", sure it's a Ray Wilson-led Genesis track, but one of the very few unreleased studio tracks by Genesis to have leaked to the collector's. Disc One: 1970-1972 01 Looking For Someone (February 22nd, 1970 BBC Radio) 02 The Light (March 7th, 1971 - later morphed into "Lillywhite Lilith" and "The Colony Of Slippermen") 03 Twilight Alehouse (February 22nd, 1972 Civic Hall, Dunstable, U.K.) 04 Harlequin (March 4th, 1972 Technical College, Watford, England) 05 Bye Bye Johnny (April 14th, 1972 Palasport, Pavia, Italy - early version of "Can-Utility And The Coastliners") 06 Happy The Man (April 18th, 1972 Piper Club, Rome, Italy) 07 Going Out To Get You (April 18th, 1972 Piper Club, Rome, Italy) 08 One-Handed Drum Solo (June 28th, 1972 Town Hall, Watford, England) 09 Can-Utility And The Coastliners (August 20th, 1972 Piper 2000 Club, Via Reggio, Italy) 10 Seven Stones (August 22nd, 1972 Teatro Alcione, Genoa, Italy - rarely ever played live) Disc Two: 1972-1975 01 Supper's Ready (November 18th, 1972 Imperial College, London, England) 02 Harold The Barrel (January 20th, 1974 Palasport, Reggio Emilia, Italy - only 2 live versions exist) 03 Horizons (May 4th, 1974 Academy of Music, NYC) 04 Watcher Of The Skies (January 24th, 1975 Shrine Auditorium, Los Angeles) 05 It (January 24th, 1975 Shrine Auditorium, Los Angeles) 06 The Musical Box (January 24th, 1975 Shrine Auditorium, Los Angeles) 07 The Waiting Room (May 2nd, 1975 Hippodrome, Birmingham, England) Disc Three: 1977-1978 01 Lillywhite Lillith - The Waiting Room - Wot Gorilla (January 1st, 1977 Rainbow, London, England) 02 All In A Mouse's Night (January 2nd, 1977 Rainbow, London, England) 03 Inside And Out (June 24th, 1977 Earl's Court, London, England) 04 Down And Out (June 7th, 1978 Scandinavium, Gothenburg, Sweden) 05 Supper's Ready (June 14th, 1978 Westfalenhalle, Dortmund, Germany) 06 Ballad Of Big (July 29th, 1978 MSG, New York City) 07 I Know What I Like (July 29th, 1978 MSG, New York City) 08 Dancing With The Moonlit Knight - Musical Box (October 13th, 1978 Uptown Theater, Chicago, Illinois) Disc Four: 1980-1984 01 Back In NYC (June 29th, 1980 MSG, New York City) 02 Me And Virgil (September 27, 1981 Velodromo Anoeta, San Sebastian, Spain) 03 Like It Or Not (November 30th, 1981 Capital Center, Landover, Maryland) 04 The Knife (December 23rd, 1981 NEC, Birmingham, England) 05 No Reply At All (featuring Phenix Horns) (August 22nd, 1982 Forest Hills, New York City) 06 Paperlate (featuring Phenix Horns) (August 22nd, 1982 Forest Hills, New York City) 07 11th Earl Of Mar / Squonk / Firth Of Fifth (November 10th, 1983 Mecca Arena, Milwaukee, Wisconsin) 08 11th Earl Of Mar / Behind The Lines / Firth Of Fifth / Musical Box (January 7th, 1984 McNichols Arena, Denver, Colorado) Disc Five: 1986-1998 01 In The Cage / ...In That Quiet Earth / Supper's Ready (October 15th, 1986 Forum, Los Angeles) 02 Mama (May 9th, 1992 Astrodome, Houston, Texas) 03 Carpet Crawlers (October 23rd, 1992 Mayflower Theater, Southampton, England) 04 Nowhere Else To Turn (Unreleased 1997 B-Side - Ray Wilson on lead vocals) 05 Small Talk (December 13th, 1997 RTL Studios, Paris, France) 06 Thats All (January 23rd, 1998 Bray Studios, London, England - only Ray Wilson version) 07 Hold On My Heart (January 29th, 1998 Sport Hall, Budapest, Hungary)

Audience 9.5 - Beautiful sound, excellent performance. A venerable Italian prog band that achieved critical success by virtue of having composed soundtrack music for horror films in the 70’s. Goblin - 2011-11-07 Kawasaki Japan, Italian Progressive Rock Festival Teatro TOKYO - KAWASAKI - CLUBCITTA' Setlist DISC 1 1 - Opening 2 - Magic Thriller 3 - Mad Puppet 4 - Dr. Frankenstein 5 - Roller 6 - E Sueno Rock 7 - Non Ho Sonno - Death Farm 8 - Goblin (inc. Drum Solo) 9 - L'alba Dei Morti Viventi - Zombi DISC 2 1 - Suspiria 2 - Tenebre 3 - Band Intros 4 - Phenomena 5 - Profondo Rosso 6 - Zaratozom 7 - Aquaman 8 - Ending Line Up Claudio Simonetti (keys) Massimo Morante (guitar) Maurizio Gaurini (keys) Bruno Previtali (bass) Titta Tani (drums)

Audience 9.4 - PFM is perhaps the archetype Italian progressive rock band, having achieved international acclaim they opened the doors for the world to discover this style of music. PFM IN CLASSIC - 2011-11-07 Kawasaki Japan, Italian Progressive Rock Festival Teatro TOKYO - KAWASAKI - CLUBCITTA' Setlist DISC 1 1 - Intro 2 - Il Flauto Magico-Overture(Mozart) 3 - Danza Macabra(Saint-Saensj / Danza Slava No.1(Dvorjak) 4 - Sinfonia No.5-IV Movimento. Adagietto(Mahler) 5 - Romeo & Giulietta-Danza Dei Cavalieri(Prokofievj 6 - La Grande Pasqua Russa(Korsakov) 7 - Nabucco- Overture (Verdi) DISC 2 1 - River Of Life 2 - Promenade The Puzzle 3 - DoveQuando 4 - Maestro Della Voce 5 - Impressioni Di Settembre (Encore) 6 - Suite Italiana: Sinfonia No.4- L'ltallana (Mendellson) – Celebration - La Danza (Rossini) 7 - William Tell Overture (Rossini) 8 - Bonus Track - La Luna Nuova (Milano, Teatro degli Arcimboldi, 23.09.2011) Line Up Franco Mussida: chitarre, voce Franz Di Cioccio: voce, batteria, percussioni Patrick Djivas: basso Lucio Fabbri: violino Gianluca Tagliavini: tastiere Roberto Gualdi: batteria  

Audience 8.7 - This recording is very hard to distinguish between audience or soundboard. I guess the later, but who knows?  Either way, it’s pretty good. Peter Gabriel Parco Delle Cascine Firenze, Italy Sept. 28, 1980 Disc 1 1 -Intruder 2 -The Start 3 -I Don't Remember 4 -Solsbury Hill 5 -Family Snapshot 6 -Milgram's 37 7 -Modern Love 8 -Not One Of Us 9 -Lead A Normal Life Disc 2 10 -Moribund The Burgermeister 11 -Mother Of Violence 12 -Humdrum 13 -Games Without Frontiers 14 -And Through The Wire 15 -I Go Swimming 16 -Biko 17 -On The Air 18 -Here Comes The Flood

Audience 9.5 - Thoroughly enjoyable from start to finish. The only thing that prevents an even higher rating is some occasional conversation around the taper, not that it ever rises to an infuriating level or anything, but it sometimes calls to your attention. I still can’t figure out the concertgoer who simply cannot focus their attention on the performance they have spent good money on seeing and hearing. Jean-Luc Ponty An afternoon at the Music Inn, Lenox, Mass.U.S.A. July 24, 1977 (opener for Renaissance) setlist: 1. -tuning and sound adjustments 2:48 2. -Tarantula 12:43 3. -Imaginary Voyage 24:11 4. -Gardens Of Babylon 5:39 5. -Band Intros 1:17 6. -Wandering On The Milky Way 1:53 7. -Fight For Life 9:55 8. -New Country 3:19 Jean-Luc Ponty- violin Allan Zavod- keyboards Daryl Stuermer- guitar Ralph Armstrong- bass Steve Smith- drums

Audience 8.5 - Pretty middle of the road, not annoying or bad, but not crystal clear. Hard to hear any detail in the guitars, it’s on the bassy side, so it’s bass and Jagger, and some locomotive sound which could be Keith and Ronnie. I mean, it is clear enough, it’s not a “bad” tape at all – in fact listening closely I am tempted to say this was pulled from a video source. THE ROLLING STONES SUPERDOME NEW ORLEANS, LOUISIANA JULY 13, 1978 Let It Rock All Down The Line Honky Tonk Woman Star Star When The Whip Comes Down Beast Of Burden Lies Miss You Just My Imagination Shattered Respectable Far Away Eyes Love In Vain Tumbling Dice Happy Sweet Little Sixteen Brown Sugar Jumping Jack Flash Street Fighting Man

Audience 9.4 - Beautiful and well balanced, this taper was well known to have produced consistently high quality work in the area taping a variety of concerts big and small. Band was opening for Badfinger, and this is the earlier of the two performances that day. This is one of the only extant live recordings of Big Star playing in the ‘70s that has not been officially released. Big Star Performance Center Cambridge, MA March 31, 1974 (early show) 01 In The Street 02 Baby Strange (T. Rex cover) 03 Mod Lang 04 Candy Says (Velvet Underground cover) 05 Till The End Of The Day (Kinks cover) 06 O My Soul 07 Motel Blues (Loudon Wainwright III cover) 08 Thirteen 09 Way Out West 10 September Gurls 11 Come On Now (Kinks Cover)