-
Soundboard 9.3 - Well balanced and full of life, not a typically sterile board. -
Audience 7.3 - Distant and narrow, but seems like a good mastering can fix some of the limitations. Needs a stereo widening and some punch in the mids and highs. -
Audience 9.4 - I rate this one very high because not only does it capture the performance in solid detail, but it also manages to capture that indefinable thing called vibe. This show has major vibe. Get it! -
Soundboard 9.3 - Not a pure board, there is some ambiance mixed in from the audience. I think this was a broadcast, it’s quite good! -
Soundboard 9.3 - Peter sounds superb here, the tape highlights him in particular. Great! -
Audience 7.7 - A real “middle of the crowd” recording. You get to eavesdrop on some conversations while Genesis perform their hits. Now, I will say this, there’s a lot of music to sink into here, it’s not THAT bad really. Give it a chance. -
Audience 8.4 - This tape was made by a very sincere taper, you can clearly tell the person tried very hard to make it work. I think, if I had to guess, the problem was not him, it was more than likely improper microphone type and simple passage of time, because this is a clear and strong tape that falls a little short in some aspects making it a little above average where it could have been amazing. The tape struggles through The Lamia, where you get the effects of age and degradation. The audio quality suffers a little bit because of distance, and that robs some dynamics and clarity, but here’s the thing: The equipment was good quality and that comes through as you do get a certain realism, a sense of the venue and atmosphere that the open mic captures. The stereo field on this tape is pretty wide, so my guess is that microphones were hoisted above the audience somewhere middle of the arena. I think I like this tape in some regards, and I definitely do not consider it rubbish and neither will you. One last thought – I found this recording did slowly improve as the show progressed, perhaps dipping a bit at the end of disc one but not catastrophically. Genesis Palace Theater Providence, RI December 8th, 1974 Disc 1 01 Introduction 1:15 02 The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway 4:59 03 Fly On A Windshield 2:31 04 Broadway Melody Of 1974 2:10 05 Cuckoo Cuckoon 2:14 06 In The Cage 8:01 07 The Grand Parade Of Lifeless Packaging 3:05 08 The Story Of Rael -Part I 2:45 09 Back In N.Y.C. 5:53 10 Hairless Heart 2:24 11 Counting Out Time 3:46 12 Carpet Crawlers 5:38 13 Chamber Of 32 Doors 5:49 Total Time 50:30 Disc 2 01 The Story Of Rael -Part II 3:08 02 Lilywhite Lilith 2:53 03 The Waiting Room 5:48 04 Anyway 3:24 05 Here Comes The Supernatural Anaesthetist 2:27 06 Interlude 1:16 07 The Lamia 7:04 08 Silent Sorrow In Empty Boats 3:28 09 The Colony Of Slippermen 8:34 10 Ravine 1:42 11 The Light Dies Down On Broadway 3:31 12 Riding The Scree 4:26 13 In The Rapids 2:06 14 It 4:53 15 The Story Of Henry And Cynthia 2:33 16 The Musical Box 13:12 17 Watcher Of The Skies 8:17 Total Time 78:52 -
Audience 7.5 - Clear but lacking depth (Early Show). -
Audience 7.6 - This tape is very clear but has low levels and is somewhat narrow in bandwidth. By turning the volume up, and adding some personal touches on EQ you can lift the experience to a little higher level. -
Soundboard 9.1 - Technically sounds good, bright, crisp and all that, but I am not in love with the overall sound mix. It’s serviceable though. -
Audience 8.5 - Starts off a little funky as the taper gets in position but slowly develops into a very good and clear recording for the duration. The audience is golden, very respectful and this makes for a better overall experience too. -
Audience 9.0 - Tape starts off funky, but quickly gets sorted and becomes quite excellent. Clear, with some nice atmosphere and decent dynamics (not overwhelming but nice). GENESIS Messezentrum Halle A Nuremberg, Germany March 27, 1975 Disc 1 1.1 The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway 4:12 1.2 Fly On A Windshield 2:38 1.3 Broadway Melody Of 1974 2:16 1.4 Cuckoo Cocoon 2:25 1.5 In The Cage 7:58 1.6 The Grand Parade Of Lifeless Packaging 3:08 1.7 Back In NYC 6:09 1.8 Hairless Heart 2:46 1.9 Counting Out Time 3:43 1.10 The Carpet Crawlers 5:46 1.11 The Chamber Of 32 Doors 5:39 1.12 Lilywhite Lilith 3:01 1.13 The Waiting Room 8:06 1.14 Anyway 3:32 1.15 Here Comes The Supernatural Anaesthetist 2:37 Disc 2 2.1 The Lamia 8:43 2.2 Silent Sorrow In Empty Boats 3:20 2.3 The Colony Of Slippermen 9:02 2.4 Ravine 1:26 2.5 The Light Dies Down On Broadway 3:30 2.6 Riding The Scree 4:19 2.7 In The Rapids 2:29 2.8 it 4:15 2.9 The Musical Box story 3:39 2.10 The Musical Box (cuts off) 1:44 Peter Gabriel: vocals, flute Phil Collins: drums, percussion, vocals Steve Hackett: guitars Tony Banks: keyboards Michael Rutherford: bass, bass pedals, 12-string guitar -
Audience 9.3 - A nicely done job this one. A warm sound, with emphasis on clear and crisp drums, bright vocals, detailed bass, and percussive keys but all in all really I find the sound mix relaxing and I sank right into this recording for the duration. You will too. Genesis Newcastle City Hall Newcastle, UK. 4-30-1980 Disc 1 01 Deep In The Motherlode 02 Dancing With The Moonlit Knight 03 Carpet Crawlers 04 Squonk 05 One For The Vine 06 The Story Of Albert 07 Behind The Lines 08 Duchess 09 Guide Vocal 10 Turn It On Again 11 Duke's Travels 12 Duke's End Disc 2 11 Say It's Alright Joe 12 The Lady Lies 13 Ripples 14 Band Introduction 15 In The Cage 16 The Colony Of Slippermen 17 Afterglow 18 Follow You, Follow Me 19 Dance On A Volcano 20 Drum Duet 21 Los Endos 22 I Know What I Like 23 The Knife -
Audience 9.1 - A beautiful recording with a terrific drum sound, and expansive, atmospheric ensemble mix of all instruments especially keyboards to pair with that drum sound. This might be one you go to frequently. Genesis 1978.07.29 Madison Square Garden, N.Y.C. The Set List: Disc 1 01 -intro 02 -Eleventh Earl of Mar 03 -In The Cage 04 -Burning Rope 05 -Ripples 06 -Deep In The Motherlode 07 -Fountains of Salmacus 08 -Ballad Of Big 09 -One For The Vine Disc 2 10 -Squonk 11 -Intro to Say It's Alright Joe 12 -Say It's Alright Joe 13 -The Lady Lies 14 -Cinema Show 15 -Afterglow 16 -Follow You, Follow Me 17 -Dance On A Volcano 18 -Drum Duet 19 -Los Endos 20 -I Know What I Like (with Peter Gabriel) -
Audience 8.9 - Strong stuff! A must! -
Audience 7.6 - Has a kind of thin quality to it even though you can hear everything on stage. Sounds like it needs a nice big punch in the middle, someone needs to remaster this one. Not crappy, just needs a mastering job. -
Audience 7.7 - A wide stereo feel, a touch of that large hall sound, pretty clear with a decent mix. Some audience chatter. -
Audience 8.7 - A surprisingly decent tape surfaces from Italy where Genesis found initial acceptance in the early part of their career. Sound is clear for the most part, and the timbre is pleasing to the ear…if I can knock it I would say maybe it is a bit compressed in the middle, so no crispness in the highs nor definition in the low end but it’s not the kind of compression that you get from, say, a video tape. It’s quite good like I said so feel secure if you get it knowing it will be worthwhile. Genesis Palasport Naples, Italy February 6, 1974 Disc 1 1. -Watcher Of The Skies 2. -Drum Improv 3. -Dancing With The Moonlit Knight 4. -Cinema Show 5. -I Know What I like 6. -Firth Of Fifth 7. -The Musical Box Disc 2 1. -More Fool Me 2. -The Battle Of Epping Forest 3. -Supper's Ready 4. -The Knife -
Audience 8.2 - Vocals a little buried, all music pretty clear and detailed. -
Audience 8.3 - Sounds kind of distant, but because it is not echoey you can adjust and then place yourself in the seat of the taper. -
Audience 8.6 - Right down in there with the crowd, listening to the audience listening to the band. The band and their music sound terrific, the audio quality is actually pretty darn good, bright, not distorted, maybe not as full on the bottom end but the bass itself is very round but not thumping. Drums are crisp and well defined. This is actually a good recording! -
Soundboard 9.3 - Simply a MUST HAVE if you have any interest at all in Genesis. Includes some backstage interviews, giving an amazing perspective of this epic show. Enchanting! -
Audience 8.3 - This recording is balancing very finely on the borderline but thankfully falls onto the “acceptable” side. I would call it slightly above average maybe, as the tape shows some typical age limitations, but still manages to present the evening in a listenable quality. Must have been a small audience at this show, crowd response is weak, but the band still perform admirably. Guzman Theatre, Miami, FL. March 9th, 1974 Disc 1- Watcher Of The Skies
- Dancing With The Moonlit Knight
- The Cinema Show
- I Know What I Like
- Firth Of Fifth
- The Musical Box
- More Fool Me
- The Battle Of Epping Forest
- Supper's Ready
-
Audience 8.7 - The tape is new to circulation and it’s a good one. The rating reflects only that there is a lack of dynamics in the bandwidth of the tape but the clarity is decent and it is a comfortable listen – not harsh, not muddy, not brittle…it’s a good tape and I am glad it was discovered. Genesis Free Trade Hall Manchester, UK February 24, 1973 1. Watcher of the Skies 2. Musical Box 3. Get 'em out by Friday 4. Suppers Ready 5. Return of the Giant Hogweed 6. The Knife (encore) -
Audience 8.7 - This tape is surprisingly clear, it is not super dynamic but it is nice and clear. It’s almost like a REALLY good AM radio broadcast. It has a narrow sound field, but it is comfortable there, and comfortable to your ears. Phil sounds like he’s singing right next to you, pretty cool. Genesis Dane County Coliseum Madison, WI. 1977-02-09 Disc 1 01. SQUONK 02. ONE FOR THE VINE 03. ROBBERY ASSUALT AND BATTERY 04. YOUR OWN SPECIAL WAY 05. FIRTH OF FIFTH 06. CARPET CRAWL 07. IN THAT QUIET EARTH 08. AFTERGLOW Disc 2 09. I KNOW WHAT I LIKE 10. 11th EARL OF MAR 11. SUPPERS READY 12. DANCE ON A VOLCANO-DRUM DUET - LOS ENDOS 13. LAMB LIES DOWN ON BROADWAY - MUSICAL BOX -
Audience 7.8 -
Audience 8.9 - Very nice and clear with the keyboards more up front this time. Bass sounds sweet too. A great recording! -
Audience 9.1 - A strong, very clear tape which has a deep bottom end, you can feel the kick and the bass! The band sound close, there’s no indication they are playing a large venue, it’s almost kind of an intimate sound. A superb taping job! Genesis Long Beach Arena Long Beach, CA May 24, 1980 Disc 1 01 Deep In The Motherlode 02 Dancing With The Moonlit Knight 03 Squonk 04 One For The Vine 05 Story Of Albert 06 Behind The Lines 07 Duchess 08 Guide Vocal 09 Turn It On Again 10 Duke's Travels - Duke's End Disc 2 11 Say It's Alright Joe 12 The Lady Lies 13 Ripples 14 Band Introduction 15 Misunderstanding 16 In The Cage 17 Afterglow 18 Follow You, Follow Me 19 Dance On A Volcano 20 Drum Duet - Los Endos 21 I Know What I Like -
Rehearsal - Soundboard 9.3 -
Soundboard 9.5 - Superb clarity and attenuation, especially where the high end is concerned. Very lifelike, no sign of radio compression which suggests this tape to be pre-FM broadcast. Genesis Hammersmith Odeon London, UK June 10, 1976 Band: Tony Banks: keyboards (pianos, synths, organ, Mellotron,) 12-string guitar, backing vocals Phil Collins: lead and backing vocals, drums, percussion Steve Hackett: lead guitars Mike Rutherford: basses, guitars, vocals Bill Bruford: drums, percussion Setlist: Disc 1 01 Dance On A Volcano 6:45 02 The Lamb Lies Down On Broadway 4:44 03 Fly On A Windshield 2:38 04 The Carpet Crawlers 6:43 05 The Cinema Show 12:30 06 Robbery, Assault And Battery 6:28 07 White Mountain 7:26 08 Firth Of Fifth 9:48 09 Entangled 6:43 10 Squonk 6:54 Runtime: 70:43 Disc 2 11 Supper's Ready Intro 1:25 12 Supper's Ready 24:37 13 I Know What I Like 7:05 14 Los Endos 6:51 15 It - Watcher Of The Skies 6:40 Runtime: 46:41 Total Runtime: 1:57:25 -
Soundboard 9.2 - Good show and I love how the drums sound in this mix. -
Audience 7.0 - Thin and distant